Skip to main content

TammyTalks: My 10 Thoughts on Zoë Saldaña playing Nina Simone by @IAmCoachBond

Check out this editorial submitted by @IamCoachBond on Twitter



My 10 thoughts on controversy surrounding Zoë Saldaña playing Nina Simone in an upcoming film about Nina to be released in 2013:

1) This is not, and should not be, a controversy. Period.

2) It speaks to how broken we are as a people that we actually devote time, energy, and the perception of brain cells, to a topic that boils down to light-skinned vs. dark-skinned. 

3) As Desiree Hart Sholes po
inted out, an actress should be chosen because of her talent, not because of her looks. In an ideal world you'll get talent and looks (i.e. Denzel playing Malcolm), but short of that it's a lot easier to modify looks than to make someone talented. Zoë has talent and will do a good job. And I'd bet Nina would care a lot more about the part being played accurately and well than having a splitting image of her.

4) Jill Scott's comments on the topic were great: ‘Zoe is an incredible actress. I think that there should be some work done, like a prosthetic nose would be helpful and definitely some darker make-up... If Forest Whitaker can become darker in The Last King Of Scotland then I believe Nina should be treated with that respect.

5) I sense that for some of the idiots who are making this an issue, it's more about the perception of Zoe's "blackness" than her actual skin tone, which is even more stupid. Simply because Zoë's day-to-day persona doesn't necessarily mimic Nina's doesn't mean she can't knock the role out of the park. That's precisely why she's an actress! You think they second guess Denzel because he wasn't "civil rightsy" enough in his day-to-day life to play Malcom, or Jamie Foxx because he wasn't blind enough in his day-to-day life to play Ray, or Beyonce because she wasn't a drug addict enough in her day-to-day life to play Etta? So why the hell would you second guess Zoë because she's not "black enough" in her day-to-day life. It's nothing short of fucking idiotic.

6) I'm ashamed to say that my people are the only ones who'd have a problem with the following scenario: a) Historic Black singer/activist dies. b) 10 years later, movie to be made about Historic Black singer/activist. c) Excellent Black actress chosen to play role of historic black singer/activist. And don't give me the "she's not Black" bullshit. The frequency with which you people change your definition of "black" to fit your argument in maddening. Let's not apply technical definitions where they don't belong because you're not talking about anything symbolic. Also, did you have a problem with a Puerto Rican singer playing a very Mexican Selena?

7) I'm no Nina Simone expert, but I THINK she would have had more of a problem with a singer who is low enough to sing about crispy chicken for money (Mary J. Blige) playing her, than someone who's a few shades too light.

8) Where the fuck was all of this outrage when Tyler Perry was chosen over Nzingha Stewart to direct "For Colored Girls..."? That was an ACTUAL poor choice. Come to think of it, where's the outrage over EVERYTHING Tyler Perry puts out? Gun toting, dress-donning Perry as a shucking-and-jiving grandmother is fantastic, but Zoë as Nina Simone is the end of the world. FOH!

9) Now, in defense of a Zoë alternative, if you asked me before any casting has taken place who should play Nina Simone, I would have said Viola Davis. She's an incredible actress who looks a bit more like Nina. Absent Viola (which could have not happened for any number of reason), I applaud the choice of talent over looks.

10) I wonder if some of you ever stop to think about why you care about the things you care about? Of if your opinions actually make sense. Are the days of really thinking about what you say (what it means, how it could be interpreted, how it reflects on you, how it reflects on your people) before you say it totally gone?

*sigh*








To submit articles or thoughts to be posted on TammyTalks.com email us tamara@tammytalks.com put GUEST BLOGGER in the subject line

Popular posts from this blog

The end of the Breakfast Club is near

The Breakfast Club has been on air for 9 years this month, and is going strong with ratings, engagement, and seems to be adding new markets every month...but I think the end is near.
I sound crazy right? I know you're thinking, Tammy how and why would you think that a successful morning show would have it's future in the balance? Well, there are a couple of reasons, let's go through them. I mean this could all be in my head and I’m projecting, or I could have some legitimate points and the near future will tell.
Shock jock radio value going down- The Breakfast Club has been known for it's shock jock style of radio for years. Charlemagne says the most outlandish things in interviews, creates false narratives that he doesn't even agree with for hot takes, and Envy always goes against the grain and disagrees with the masses on any given topic, just to disagree. Podcasting is huge right now, put five people in a room and at least three of them have a podcast; just at the…

15 Black women that need to host SNL

Saturday Night Live has been around for 45 years this fall and has had a series of hosts, of all ethnicities, ages, and entertainment occupations. They've had hosts that are comedians, actors, singers, rappers, and more. Now, while the diversity has been decent...I would love to see more black women as hosts. I've compiled a list of black women I think would do a damn good job at hosting the late night show. Let's get started shall we...
Tracee Ellis Ross - Tracee is a no brainer and should be at the top of everyone's list when thinking of who should host when they are doing the planning over at NBC. Tracee has perfect comedic timing, which we've seen time and time again on Girlfriends, and now on Black-ish we’ve seen her transform into Rainbow Johnson, and also into the other smaller roles they play when they have episodes within their episodes, if that makes sense. Her personality is playful and fun, which is evident through her Instagram. So, she’s topping this l…

Grown-ish is a far cry from A Different World

When it was announced that Black-ish, the hit ABC sitcom about an affluent African American family doing their best to immerse their kids in the their ethnic culture while still enjoying the fruits of their labor, would be getting a spinoff following the oldest daughter, Zoe Johnson, as she headed to college people were somewhat excited. When it was pegged to be an updated and more current version of the hit series A Different World people were more than excited and the show was highly anticipated. We were expecting to see Zoe navigate life as a college freshmen, out of the sheltered and, low key white bread, lifestyle. We were anticipating seeing her explore more of her life after highschool, then it aired…



Now, don’t get me wrong, I like Grown-ish, I think it’s entertaining, but it’s a far cry from A Different World. I didn’t expect the show that be identical to A Different World, mainly since Zoe wasn’t attending an HBCU, so there’s that, but I think the show is missing the mark on …